In the 2024 presidential election, the political gender divide among young voters was vast, as young women remained liberal-leaning, while many young men shifted to the conservative side. Between 2020 and 2024, the Democratic identification among young men dropped from a 22% advantage to a 3%, according to a Harvard Study.
So, we asked Gen Z men from both sides of the aisle to share why they believe some of their peers are growing more conservative, and their responses were truly fascinating. Here's what they had to say:
1. "My Gen Z cousins are OBSESSED with masculinity. Who they're sleeping with, how much money they're making, how many guns they own, and they're constantly trying to top each other. I think conservatives recognized this group of insecure guys and really tapped into their fears of being perceived as less masculine and their interests."
"I don't 100% blame politicians either; Joe Rogan, Andrew Tate, all of these misogynist personalities are really influencing this new generation of men that makes them feel like having conservative values is the only way to portray themselves as masculine." —jrmart91
2. "Amongst Trump's voters, I think it is a serious question of how many actually like the guy versus how many poked him with a 10-foot pole only because their faith in establishment politicians, Democrat and Republican alike, is that much worse."
"Sure, Trump is a loose cannon at best, yeah he'll probably blow up in our faces, but he is the only cannon available to fire their growing pile of grievances on the ivory towers of DC, shaking up an establishment that has been deemed ineffective at best and out of touch and self-serving at worst."
3. "Now, keep in mind that there are a lot of factors for this. There's not one cause. But as a high schooler, I really think that the cause for a lot of far-right shifts is the current mentality in and out of schools. A lot of how kids think about new and scary concepts is through jokes, and that's fine, but if we give that too much of a platform in middle school, suddenly, it's all over the place in high school. Making fun of their female peers, joking about kidnapping and assaulting people, it's real."
"Teachers just won't address it. That trivializes extremely important real-world concepts. From there, it's just a short jump to voting red in the next election. It's really, really sad. I spend all day interacting with people who I used to consider friends who now regularly make fun of my sexuality."
4. "We live in a loneliness epidemic, and media personalities like Joe Rogan, Ben Shapiro, and Matt Walsh provide scapegoats. For young men who are still figuring themselves out, these social media rabbit holes are very easy to fall down. I would know; I nearly did myself during the pandemic."
"These people thrive off fear, and when you’re young, you have a lot of fear that these people take advantage of. The villain isn’t women, it’s not people of color, it’s not LGBTQ+ people that are just trying to live their lives. It’s people who take advantage of fear."
5. "What does the left offer to men? There is no positive example or archetype held up by the left in a way that can be appealing like right-wing figures are to young men."
"Liberal men are portrayed as a subset of the evils of all men and specifically have a history of being corrupt or creepy. Nobody wants to grow up to be Gavin Newsom or Andrew Cuomo. It is a messaging failure in the same vein as many leftist messaging failures; they have the policy but know nothing about old-fashioned politics."
6. "For too long, messaging from the left focused upon (rightfully) shaming men who perpetuate patriarchal bro culture that directly harms women. Young men need positive reinforcement and to feel valued, and unfortunately, the right has really taken advantage of that gap."
"No matter how flawed and downright awful the lessons are from conservatives, they still offer young men a vision of confidence and pride." —Frooby