Ugly/sexy and charismatic dudes

We have this thread all the damn time. And every time I say Lee Marvin.

And every time you are right, R1.

Elliot Page

OP was Jeremy Renner supposed to be Jeremy Irons?

R4, no.

I would put Jeremy Irons in the category of David Tennant, Christian Bale, Robert Downey Jr. and James Spader as unconventionally beautiful dudes.

Christian Bale "unconventionally attractive"???

The OG: Jean-Paul Belmondo.

R6, Bale is not classically good looking. His face and features are rather narrow and he can look completely goofy.

I see your Willem Dafoe and raise you a Steve Buscemi, OP.

I find both of them unconventionally sexy.

Sam Elliott was never ugly.

Adam Driver

Yul Brynner.

Charles Bronson- So hot ca. 1974

I bet he had a python 🐍 between his legs.

Beau-laid is a term that may apply to these - beautiful ugly.

Benedict Cumberbatch

Benicio Del Toro

Eddie Redmayne

Actually 90% of the top male British actors in the past 20-25 years. Seriously.

Richard Crenna.

Telly Savalis.

Billy Bob Thornton. He’s hot.

James Spader and Robert Downey Jr “unconventionally beautiful”? Hell no. They were straight up pretty during the 80s.

Who thought Richard Crenna (Luke McCoy) was ugly?

Adrien Brody.

Adam driver is unsexy ugly.

I never thought about Lee Marvin but indeed Sylvia is correct.

I mean, I guess if we say Lee we also say Bogart. He was sort of a taller, darker version of the same.

Adam Driver has the charisma of a damp rag.

I don’t loathe Jeremy Allen White and he’s not an asshole like Chalamet but I don’t think he’s very charismatic and frankly I don’t think his acting is that special.

But Jeremy IS hot as fuck. Dog eyed face but banging body.

Jason Clarke - sometimes ugly, sometimes hot, great actor.

R18, Crenna wasn't always young, duh.

Michael Caine - Pale and freckled with puffy eyelids, he was never handsome, but he dominated the screen.

Sam Elliott was sexy when he was young, too.

I personally do think Adam Driver is ugly sexy. Also Willem Dafoe.

Oh, and Tim Curry!

Daniel Craig and Jeremy Renner look similar. They could play brothers. Fuckable.

Matt Gaetz

R17 straight-up pretty is not conventionally handsome.

I know you're joking, but it has to be said: Matt Gaetz is beyond repulsive.

James McAvoy? What does DL think about him?

Billy Bob Thornton.

Yes to both R34 and R35.

Jeremy Allen White's Calvins ad is a throwback to the great homoerotic campaigns of the 80s.

He looks so desperate to masturbate.

Such a sweet, tight little body.