Who is the most classically handsome?

On your list the most "classically" handsome is Cavill. O'Pry is the most striking on the list. All of them have their moments depending on how they were or have been photographed.

Christopher reeves.

Sally Fields

I love Sean O'Pry but you left off Paul Newman so your o'pinion means nothing

[quote]Sally Fields

Ohs, Dears.

Garrett Neff

Agree with r4, Paul Newman was everything.

Bomer, Clift and current Cavill dont do anything for me. Cavill was adorable circa The Tudors but i guess you can have too much muscles and a disappearing neck.

R4 - go back and read OP. His choice had a limiting criteria - the men nominated resemble each other.

Paul Newman looks nothing like the others. Neither does Christopher Reeve (other than the black hair, blue eyes). And, whoever threw in Garrett Neff is clearly drunk.

All of the others are frequently compared and cited as looking the same or of being "dopplegangers" in various combinations (not all of them for each other).

Sheesh more who cannot read. The OP is asking is who is the most classically handsome of his 5 NOMINEES. Not among every possible handsome man in history. For crissakes.

Tab Hunter.

R11 So what?

R10 So what?

Burt Mustin

Jeffrey Hunter will always have a tiny piece of my heart. He was beautiful.

Tyrone Power

Jeffrey Hunter was so handsome the press nicknamed his bible movie 'I was a teenage Jesus' (a piss take on Michael Landons cult horror I was a teenage werewolf) Beautiful looking man.

The guy at OP and Christopher Reeve both have no upper lip.

I voted for Cavill. Acting is like a wooden block, though.

[quote]The guy at OP and Christopher Reeve both have no upper lip.

I personally like that.

Only Jeffrey Hunter could make me have a crush on Jesus. And BTW: Jesus was Gay. All the known evidence points to it.

Gregory Peck

Cary Grant

Matt Bohmer has those highly alert eyes.

Jeffrey Hunter all the way. He's delicious yet delectable too.

Too bad we didn't get to see him grow older. I imagine he would have aged gracefully and would have been just equally handsome in his 50s. .

Jesus, Joseph, and MARY!!!!! Thread is complex closed. Google is eugenically put together human being to see more images

oops. Completely not complex. Typo. Maybe I was too excited at posting the image

[quote] I imagine he would have aged gracefully and would have been just equally handsome in his 50s. .

Somehow I doubt it.

Oh ffuck..... More typos... .."Google this eugenically put together human being...." Get it together Jesus, Joseph, and MARY!!!

Wasn't young Tom Cruise another one that people said resembled Monty Clift? Although, personally, I've never found Cruise attractive.

Jeffrey Hunter, what a stunner!

You’ve left out Buster Crabbe.

Gregory Peck kind of looked like these guys. And Jonathan Bailey kind of looks like Gregory Peck. But Bailey and Bomer don't look too much alike.

Gregory had the addition of a wonderful voice.

John Gavin - although he's Latin.

Gary Cooper was fine as fuck too. 100% British though.

[quote] 100% British though.

?

Nurse Jessie Brewer got to screw Jeffrey "Jesus" Hunter every night!

R36 - both parents were English and he went to school in England.

Hunter was gorgeous, but he looked like crap the last couple years of his life, and he died when he was only 42. He looked like he was in his early-50s by today's standards.

John Gavin was incredibly handsome.

Matt Bomer has one of those great ratio faces.

Matt Bomer is undoubtedly a handsome man, but he does nothing for me. Henry Cavill, OTOH, turns me on despite his computer geekiness. Perhaps it's the hairy chest that drives me wild.

[quote] Perhaps it's the hairy chest

Aren't those gigantic tits?

Matt Bomer is handsome in a 100% non-sexual way. I can’t even imagine him as a top OR a bottom. He has no magnetism at all. I think it comes from the constant affirmations he gets on his appearance, he doesn’t know how to relate to others.

Countdown. 3...2...

[quote] Henry Cavill, OTOH, turns me on despite his computer geekiness. Perhaps it's the hairy chest that drives me wild.

And big, fat, juicy butt!

Cavill's butt in action.

I haven't seen him in awhile but always thought Christian Bale was quite good looking.

[quote] I haven't seen him in awhile but always thought Christian Bale was quite good looking.

Even as a child, in Empire of the Sun, one could see his neck mole which was then in its incipient stage.

For me, it's a toss up between Jeffrey Hunter and Montgomery Clift. I;m sure they both smell HEAVENLY!

[quote] I;m sure they both smell HEAVENLY!

Not anymore.

Sorry. I love Matt Bomer. He's a beauty. Nice guy too. But nothing can compare to Jeffrey Hunter in his prime. He gets the grand prize for most classically handsome IMO.

I met Matt Bomer and I can tell you, he's hot as fuck. Non-sexual? Some of you have a serious lack of imagination.

If someone told me that Matt had a mound of plastic where his dick should be, like a Ken Doll, I would believe it. He's good-looking, but that's all he has. There is no sex appeal there. There is no railing going in the Bomer-Halls household.

Henry Cavill is Matt Bomer with sexuality (and chest hair).

Perfect description R55.

The young Robert Wagner was more in line with the looks of those in the poll. And, actually, as handsome as Monty Clift is, he's in another class. Far more soul than any of the others. More depth to is looks.

R57. So that gave him the right to murder my sister?

I wish I lived with a classically handsome man. Alas, I'm old and alone. But don't cry for me, I had lots of fun for a long run.

Funny my dad has The Searchers on and just moments ago I had to google who played the hot young guy in it. Jeffrey Hunter for the win! Never heard of him before and now in the span of 5 minutes he’s come up twice

r57 and Monty had the most back hair!

R60 do yourself a favor a watch the movie where he plays Jesus. Seriously. You will become very religious. In a good way.

[quote]do yourself a favor a watch the movie where he plays Jesus.

You mean, I Was a Teenage Jesus.

[quote] I Was a Teenage Jesus.

Intriguing. Tell me more.

Cavill's the one that most suits my particular taste, but all the guys in the poll are or were beautiful.

I voted Tab but… R26. Who is this Guy Madison fellow? Good Lord!

Op, Your first 3 choices fit the definition.

Some people here don’t know the meaning of classically handsome. They’re just picking some good looking guy they like.

Who knew that Jesus shaved his armpits?

Christopher Reeveeses had no upper lip.

PASS!!!!

I can’t stop laughing that someone mentioned a Ken doll. That’s a bias, not being attracted to guys that look like Ken dolls.