Who was hotter, Marlon Brando or Paul Newman?

Brando.

No contest: Paul Newman.

Absence of Malice, circa 1981, was on TCM earlier this week. Even at 56, Newman was still very doable. Brando was bloated and fat already at that age.

Let's hope the grease fire for trolling dullards such as this OP is hotter than either of the gentleman mentioned.

Paul Newman is the hottest ever.

Brando at his hottest was better looking than Newman at his hottest I cannot unsee what Brando looked like at the end.

At his peak, Brando was heartbreakingly sexy. But he lost his looks early. Paul Newman was good looking even when he was much older.

Paul Newman looked like an actual Greek God.

Brando, in his prime, by a mile.

I think Newman was at his peak beauty as Brick in COAHTR.

For pure sex appeal, however, I prefer Newman's mature, Silver Daddy phase in "The Verdict".

Old Markon no. Young Marlon yes. Why ask OP - I’ll have them both (young) May I vote for young Ruter Hauer OP?

Rutger

Marlon was obviously hot but he just seemed like such an asshole, that it turns me off from him.

Paul Newman was a lot more conventionally handsome.

"Hotter," as in "sexier," I'd say Brando in his prime was hotter.

Brando was hot for about 15 minutes. Paul Newman was always hot.

Both hot, but Brando is more my style

Brando was HOTTER, Newman was prettier.

Brando. But Newman made better films

Kinda gets old hearing about how hot Brando and Newman were. People need to show love to some of the other Old Hollywood hotties.

Dana Andrews. But he was a sot. And a nasty one. But he got his act together and became a spokesman for AA .

Both Paul Newman (Ohio) and Marlon Brando (Nebraska) were from the Midwest.

So were Rock Hudson (Illinois), Robert Wagner (Michigan), and James Dean (Indiana).

R18 Incidentally, I recently got into Dana Andrews.

I stumbled upon BALL OF FIRE on YouTube and watched it because of Miss Barbara Stanwyck, but I ended up falling for him.

I subsequently watched LAURA, STATE FAIR, and THE BEST YEARS OF OUR LIVES and now I'm in love. 😂

I love his wavy, dark hair and handsome, affable face and smiling eyes.

Very much my type.

And he was a Texas boy! 😍

Paul Newman remained a beautiful man into his old age. Brando turned into a bloated wreck.

Tough one. Depends on your type. Newman was a pretty boy, but Brando was an aloof, egotistical, HOT, mess of a man. Team Brando.

Brando had the better body in his prime.

Brando at his peak was truly sublime. Newman looked to me like a gigolo.

^ THE PROOF, BITCHES!

R20, I love you! Dana Andrews was hotter than hot, not to mention a world-class acting talent; and, by all accounts, a lovely and decent man who respected his longtime marriage and was much-loved by his family.

Newman had an impossibly handsome face but he had scrawny arms and legs.

Newman since he didn't get fat and ugly

I'd take James Dean over both of them.

Brando in Streetcar was hotter than Newman in anything.

Brando gets a point for liking BBC

Didn’t Quincy Jones spill the beans on how Brando and Richard Pryor used to fuck?

Brando had an ugly voice, Newman's voice was sexy.

Newman and Dean’s attraction to each other was obvious in this audition clip…

Newman was good looking but boring and extremely devoted to his wife. Brando was unhinged, a mess and was likely great in bed. Since I have bad taste—Brando by a long shot. And nobody was ever better looking than Brando in Streetcar.

That image of Brando is digitally altered. The cock, in the unedited image, is much smaller and not black.

R34 Newman was so hot and bothered, he was pitting out like crazy. His white shirt is soaked underneath the armpits.

I’ve never seen another version of the Brando fellatio pic. The only ones I’ve seen are the black cock.

With outta doubt Brando....untill he became a whale of an actor.

Brando

Newman was the dreamy frat boy who’d make out with you at the drive-in.

Brando was the townie who’d fuck your throat behind the Winn-Dixie.

thread closed.