Eldergays: Who was hotter: Robert Redford or Paul Newman?

Robert Redford

Paul Newman

redford... better looking, better hair, and a much sexier body, that hairy chest! whew!.. newman had the chiseled face and those blue eyes, but nothing else...

Redford for the body hair

Then why is Paul Newman winning my poll?

They were both blue eyed matinee idols. Newman was the better actor. I thought he was better looking too.

Vivian Vance

I think Robert Redford was much better looking. He was the ultimate Ken doll. However, Newman had a lot more sex appeal. There was something dangerous about Newman that made him very sexy. Redford, not so much.

Newman was kind of small guy. Robert Redford was a big hunk, that hair, that chest, those eyes. YUMMY

Newman was sexier. Redford was prettier.

When Hubbell was drunk I wanted him to end up in my bed. That scene where he is sitting in her bed... OH MY

That scene where Hubbell is in his naval uniform, sitting drunk, eyes closed, at the bar. That image seared into my brain instantly.

"Robert Redford was a big hunk"

No, dear.

I've seen Robert Redford in real life.

Even in high heeled cowboy boots and the world's fluffiest toupee he was barely 5'9".

I voted for Newman.

But I never saw him in person so the illusion remains unbroken.

R11... i so so hear you! that scene where he is passed out on bed and only that white sheet is covering his lower body and you that glorious hairy sexy chest shown off! jack off material for me for many years now! and then to think that ole Katie (streisand) actually gets him to unknowing screw her is just so erotic and wickedly hot!...

Of course in my dirty mind, I always fantasize about Katie's "loser" wimpy friend played by a young James woods, had his way with the ultimate frat boy pretty boy stud hubbell.. Like he starts house sitting for Katie when she was gone somewhere and Hubbell would frequently stay there when he was in town and james woods character Frankie would "drug" hubbell and literally have his way with him every time unbeknownst to hubbell!....

Newman is sexier by far.

Although Redford is classically handsome, Newman radiated more heat.

I’m convinced that Redford wears a wig. My friend says no way, he’s just lucky with his hair. Is there any definite proof that he does or doesn’t?

Newman had chicken legs.

Does Boris Johnson wear a wig? Maybe they have the same hair genetics.

R18... newman had a chicken body frankly, not a hair on it either it seems... if newman didn't have those eyes, i think he would look kind of dweebish..

true masculine beauty? 2 words: steve reeves...

Paul Newman was gorgeous into old age, He was probably the most handsome old fart ever.