Which '70s actor do you wish had posed for Playgirl?

Perry King

Lyle Waggoner didn't show anything. He regretted doing it when the magazine became more explicit. Thought it ruined his reputation.

None of the above.

Like R2 said, Lyle didn't do frontal, though I wish he had (like Peter Lupus did), but I doubt it ruined his reputation. He went on to do plenty of other work, including our beloved Wonder Woman and Charlie's Angels.

But to answer your question, Estrada all the way! Frontal (and back-al) only of course!

I have always had the feeling that both Redford and Newman had nothing much going on, especially that they'd want to share with the world.

Sam Elliott

R4, I recall Estrada's wife citing his scaly feet during their divorce proceedings.

Treat Williams.

OP, Gabe Kaplan? Vivian Vance would have gotten more votes.

Perry can be seen full frontal in MANDINGO

There was a Playgirl model who looked really really like Robert Redford, maybe in some Christmas edition some years ago.

Side Note: I'm gonna get flamed the fuck out, but I absolutely would still jerk it to Ron Howard's (proposed) porn film (in which he also wanted to star), circa the late 1970s. Of course, I love gingers anyway. And I actually still think he's adorable at 67.

Paul Newman, Redford, & Ryan O'Neal are my answers to OP's poll.

R7 Estrada's feet, is that a dealbreaker? Not for me.

Also, I'm adding for Eddie Mekka, Scott Colomby, Michael Lembeck, Patrick Duffy, Donnelly Rhodes.

Estrada wore a Speedo on "Chips" you can Google it.

Brad Davis

Who’s uncut? That one.

Jon Erik Hexum Gil Gerard Boomer Esiason

R17 I thought of Hexum too, but OP said "70s actor," and Hexum didn't start acting unitl '82.

James Franciscus was hot running around in that loin cloth in that Planet of the Apes movie he did. Would've liked to have seen him without it.

*Lee Majors, agree with ^Ryan O'neal, Sam Elliott, Eric Estrada, Patrick Duffy...

Robert Urich

Larry Storch. Boomer was really hot back in the day. He hasn't aged very well.

Larry Wilcox

I always thought Wilcox was way hotter than Estrada.

Timothy Bottoms

Ryan O'Neal

Warren Beatty

I'm old as fuck, and I was only thirteen when the seventies ended. So had they posed nude I would not have been able to see them in Playgirl.

R27, the photos would still exist and you'd be able to see them naked after you were of legal age.

Gregory Harrison!!!!!!

Ronny Howard posing next to Donny Most

I think the most interesting people to see naked are the last ones you'd expect to see naked. You get to see their pubes and the length of their flaccid cocks and whether their butts are fuzzy. I voted for Gene Hackman.

William Katt would have been nice with his furry blond bush.

Gabe Kaplan

Emily Blunt admitted she had a crush on Roy Scheider.

Kent McCord

If y'all are saying you didn't want to see Travolta naked during his Saturday Night Fever/Grease heyday, you're damned liars.

Shawn and David Cassidy

Erik Estrada flashed the camera in that reality tv show he did, but they blurred it out.

I would love to see Lorenzo Lamas' Playgirl shoot at his prime right after "Grease" that his father had killed. He talks about it in his book.

Mason Reese.

Tom Jones. Chad Everett. Bobby Sherman. Mark Spitz. Donny Osmond. Alice Cooper. Elton John. John Denver. Barry Manilow. Henry Winkler.

James Caan

Gil Gerard

Tommy Lee Jones should have posed nude to promote The Eyes of Laura Mars

Thank you to those who did like Fred Williamson!

Freddie Prinze

Reb Brown

Jim Brown and Fred Williamson challenged each other to go full-frontal in Playgirl. Jim Brown did it, Fred Williamson chickened out.

They told Jim Brown he shouldn't pose full-frontal because he was a pro football hall of famer and a popular actor.

He said "fuck that!"

It didn't decrease his popularity.

Out of the list, Paul Newman who sometimes looked like he was really packing in some photos.

The fact Jim Brown had no qualms about nudity and put it in our faces gets me hard. Not just the beautiful body, but the audacity to show it all off knowing this would make the news and people would judge him for it.

Jim Brown had a huge bush.

I jerked off to the Jim Brown pictorial for many months.

Jim Brown must regret it too. I remember scanning his autobiography at a store when I was a kid looking for any dirt he had to say about his nudity. He never mentioned it.

Elliott Gould. He had a hairy back that Pauline Kael complained about, but he was kinda hot. I bet he had a huge muff and thick dong.

Marty Feldman, out of curiosity

George Maharis wanted to be shown full-frontal in his Playgirl centerfold. The magazine hedged, for whatever reason, but this photo appeared in one of the "Best of" issues later. It's about as full-frontal as he got.

Another photographer took this picture of Maharis before the Playgirl shoot.

[quote]OP: Which '70s actor do you wish had posed for Playgirl?

OP, people who are in the mood to consider preferences among these and other men prefer to have wishes about them cumming in our mouths and other sorts of things, not looking at them in your sticky old original copies of the imaginary magazines.

I mean, "show the goods"? Gurl.

R38, it was Surreal Life but he wasn't naked. He had a bathing suit on but by blurring it, it appeared as if he was naked. That was revealed on one of those compilation shows.

Estrada also said on the reality show they took them to a nudist colony to get dick shots and he wouldn't do it .Considering his co-star was Ron Jeremy, would you?

I was in total lust with Bruce Fairbairn who replaced Michael Ontkean in The Rookies. Oh, what a fabulous day when he turned up naked with his wife in Viva. Full frontal including a dick closeup.

no link to Viva r62? Was this post the TV show?

Travolta? Can’t you see her nude and importuning (or raping Queens digitally) at any Oriental Spa or Bathhouse?

Bruce Fairbairn naked . . .

John David Carson

Michael Sarrazin

Dirk Benedict

Redford with his massive blond bush and pendulous testicles. And furry ass

Leigh J. McCloskey

R67, In reading the latest biography of Gloria Swanson, I was surprised to discover that she mentored Dirk Benedict in the early days of his career and he even lived with her for a while.

R68 I never pictured Redford as packing anything more than a derringer.

[Quote] Lyle Waggoner didn't show anything. He regretted doing it when the magazine became more explicit. Thought it ruined his reputation.

Didn't he host a stripper TV show in the mid 1980s? He seemed a raunchy dude.

It was joked about on the Carol Burnett show, R72. They didn’t seem to mind, all he showed were the uppermost pubic hairs. If he had gone full-frontal, that may have made a difference.

Grant Goodeve.

Didn't Sarrazin go full frontal in that movie with Margot Kidder?

I think it was called "The Re-incarnation of Peter Proud."

One of the movies I watched repeatedly on the Z Channel because where else was I going to see dick besides my own back in junior high?

I used to know the exact point in the movie "Buster and Billie" where Jan Michael Vincent showed peen.

It was the highlight of the movie because it was incredibly depressing otherwise. (The female gets raped and murdered because she's considered a "slut")

Thankfully Robert Englund (no offense) did not get naked. Quite a few years before Nightmare on Elm Street. He played Vincent's best friend.

I'd be watching Rhoda, and then click to Z Channel for the Jan Michael dick shot.

Then back to Rhoda.

I don't know. Playgirl seemed to have of a way redering what should have been sexy photos as completely sexless . As a young gayling I headed straight for Honcho or Inches at the used mag bookstore. I never wasted my time on Playgirl.

i meant, rendering. ^^^