Who was more beautiful in their prime: Elizabeth Taylor or Madonna?

Hmmmmm

Vivian Vance

That isn't funny OP.

Janet

R3, why is it not funny?

Liz Taylor

OMG SHAT UP OP!!!!!! WTF! is your diagnosis? What do you think of Madonna's CLIT? Is it a nice clit? Who has a better cliit, Madonna or Cher? Have you ever seen a clit? II think I would like to see Madonna's clit. Would you? I would not want to touch Madonna's clit. Who was a better actress Catherine Deneuve or Elizabeth Taylor? Do French woman have nice clits than Madonna and Elizabeth Taylor? What do you think of Madonna's CLIT? Is it a nice clit? Who has a better cliit, Madonna or Cher? Have you ever seen a clit? II think I would like to see Madonna's clit. Would you? I would not want to touch Madonna's clit. Who was a better actress Catherine Deneuve or Elizabeth Taylor? Do French woman have nice clits than Madonna and Elizabeth Taylor? What do you think of Madonna's CLIT? Is it a nice clit? Who has a better cliit, Madonna or Cher? Have you ever seen a clit? II think I would like to see Madonna's clit. Would you? I would not want to touch Madonna's clit. Who was a better actress Catherine Deneuve or Elizabeth Taylor? Do French woman have nice clits than Madonna and Elizabeth Taylor? What do you think of Madonna's CLIT? Is it a nice clit? Who has a better cliit, Madonna or Cher? Have you ever seen a clit? II think I would like to see Madonna's clit. Would you? I would not want to touch Madonna's clit. Who was a better actress Catherine Deneuve or Elizabeth Taylor? Do French woman have nice clits than Madonna and Elizabeth Taylor? What do you think of Madonna's CLIT? Is it a nice clit? Who has a better cliit, Madonna or Cher? Have you ever seen a clit? II think I would like to see Madonna's clit. Would you? I would not want to touch Madonna's clit. Who was a better actress Catherine Deneuve or Elizabeth Taylor? Do French woman have nice clits than Madonna and Elizabeth Taylor? What do you think of Madonna's CLIT? Is it a nice clit? Who has a better cliit, Madonna or Cher? Have you ever seen a clit? II think I would like to see Madonna's clit. Would you? I would not want to touch Madonna's clit. Who was a better actress Catherine Deneuve or Elizabeth Taylor? Do French woman have nice clits than Madonna and Elizabeth Taylor? What do you think of Madonna's CLIT? Is it a nice clit? Who has a better cliit, Madonna or Cher? Have you ever seen a clit? II think I would like to see Madonna's clit. Would you? I would not want to touch Madonna's clit. Who was a better actress Catherine Deneuve or Elizabeth Taylor? Do French woman have nice clits than Madonna and Elizabeth Taylor? What do you think of Madonna's CLIT? Is it a nice clit? Who has a better cliit, Madonna or Cher? Have you ever seen a clit? II think I would like to see Madonna's clit. Would you? I would not want to touch Madonna's clit. Who was a better actress Catherine Deneuve or Elizabeth Taylor? Do French woman have nice clits than Madonna and Elizabeth Taylor? What do you think of Madonna's CLIT? Is it a nice clit? Who has a better cliit, Madonna or Cher? Have you ever seen a clit? II think I would like to see Madonna's clit. Would you? I would not want to touch Madonna's clit. Who was a better actress Catherine Deneuve or Elizabeth Taylor? Do French woman have nice clits than Madonna and Elizabeth Taylor?

That is like asking "Who is more handsome - Jamie Farr or Cary Grant?"

This is a stealth Janbot Madonna hate thread...

I’d say Madonna. In her prime. Like in “Take a Bow.”

I’ve never heard Elizabeth Taylor’s music. Is she related to Taylor Swift?

R9 how is this a hate thread?

Who was a better dancer in her prime, Golda Meir or Louise Nevelson?

Gaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!

You know exactly how R11...

R14 who bashed in the question?

It just asked who was more beautiful

Elizabeth Taylor of course silly. Big Madonna and Taylor Fan here.

Sally Struthers, OP!

Madonna herself would say Elizabeth. And so would I. And I'm a Madonna fan.

I’m a big Madonna fan but she was never beautiful.

Love Madonna, but Elizabeth by far.

Madonna wasn't "beautiful' in the traditional sense but she did have something about her. The way she looks in La Isla Bonita, Like a Prayer, Take a Bow and You'll See is stunning.

Oh, and Bad Girl. She looked really good in that one too.

Id say its a tie....

R23 I'd say you are visually impaired. Madonna was a badass bitch, but pure trailer trash. Liz Taylor was a classic beauty with a perfect oval face and violet eyes. Very upscale looking. It's comical to compare them.

Definitely, Vivian Vance. Liza Taylor and Madonna were turds on two legs.

It’s been said that I look like a combination of both. Madonna now and Elizabeth two years after she was buried.......

Muriel! Perhaps it's time for O.P.s to pass a battery of vision and psychologial tests before they post.

Fuck off OP

Madonna

R28 why so hostile?

Liz all the way.

Madge looks like a waitress who won a free makeover.

U ppl r harsh on madge

Elizabeth Taylor isn't attractive to me and Madonna looks like a man.

Elizabeth Taylor was extremely beautiful.

R33 who do u think is goodlooking then?

Leona Helmsley

Madge is much prettier than lizzie

I vote taylor

No, it really isn’t, OP

🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄

Is this a joke?

R40 why a joke?

Liz

Both equally beautiful

^^^ PUSSY

Dont know either one

Madonna was never a beauty; comparing her to Elizabeth Taylor is absurd.

OP is absurd or at least very simple and provincial.

This is a tough one, OP, because I’ve never considered Madonna to be beautiful.

This reminds me of an argument I recently had with a dear friend. She claims Grace Kelly was the most beautiful movie star of the 50s, while I mounted a forceful defense on behalf of Shelley Winters.

Is OP Larry King posting from beyond the grave?

After the break, We have Liza on the line...

Madonna has been captured in photos and videos looking striking and breathtakingly beautiful, but it's all mostly glam makeup, airbrushing and Photoshop. Take away the smoke and mirrors and she's pretty, but not anyway near Elizabeth Taylor's league during her heyday.

Madonna is pretty Elizabeth is beautiful

Dumb comparison

Neither

Elizabeth

Fuck off Madonna Stan! You know fat senators wife Elizabeth Taylor could wipe the floor with you in your prime. Don’t you have another african baby to expose on social media ?

R56 your post made no sense

LOL

Ma-WHO?!

Elizabeth Taylor.

Why is it even a question?

These have always brought me luck.

R51 has it right. Madonna has worked with some amazing artists and photographers over the years, but Elizabeth was more of a natural beauty.

R49, Shelley Winters has never been beautiful. Just easy. She always had trouble keeping her legs together. And down below her waist.

Who was more elegant in their prime: Bianca Jagger or Tan Mom?

Who made a greater contribution to human knowledge: Margaret Mead or Nicole Elizabeth Snooki LaValle?

Which fruit is better: plums or hot dogs?

Taylor easily

Both

Taylor in her prime

Thats like asking who is more beautiful : paris hilton or grace kelly?

Vivian Vance, obviously!

The Juilliard School, or The Sheboygan Conservatory?

Taylor of course.

Elizabeth Taylor.

What alternate universe do you live in OP, that you think this is close contest? Are you one of Madonna's delusional fans or just trolling?

Madonna has been called sexy by the press. Unlike Elizabeth, she has never been called the most beautiful woman in the world. Even in her youth, she was greatly helped by flattering lighting and makeup. They're called makeup [italic]artists[/italic] for a good reason. (R51: she had her lips injected with filler in that photo, not long after Barbara Hershey did it.)

Even Madonna would say it was Elizabeth Taylor.

Madonna aged better

cough m'kay

I still prefer Madonna look.

II eat dog turds gaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

Madonna looks hard, like the old whore that she is.

Both gorgeous

Neitherz

Who

Both r ok looking

Liz

Obviously Ms Ciccone has nothing better to do than start stupid threads on DL.....Did she really think she was going to win in such an unwinnable competition????

Gaga of course.

Madonna

Liz and it isn't even close.

No one was more beautiful than lizzie

No.

Taylor all the way

I’d say Liz was more beautiful in “traditional” way. Madonna is much more attractive however.

Taylor was beautiful in the late 50s. Madonna was never beautiful.

R93, what about the rest of the 50s?

The magnitude of Taylor's beauty could not be captured in film. That's right! A director she'd worked with claimed that she was NOT photogenic - that as beautiful as she appeared on film and pics, she was still far more beautiful in the flesh to the naked eye! Imagine that!

OP is either a troll or mentally ill.

Madonna couldn't touch Elizabeth Taylor in her prime or even when she was a bit past.

Elizabeth Taylor as Gloria Wandrous roaming around that Fifth Avenue apartment in her slip was the stuff of male fantasies for a few generations.

Then there was "Maggie the Cat" in a "Cat On A Hot Tin Roof"

More proof:

Even when dressed to the nines, Madonna still looks like an easy lay from the wrong side of the tracks.

Elizabeth Taylor wasn't only beautiful but she had class.

Oh and the camera loved Elizabeth Taylor.

Both of them really liked shoveling in community meat into their mouths in their prime. Liz at picnics, Madonna in bathroom stalls at truck stops.

Both lookalike to me

Both ok

Who

Madonna

Bump

Equal

They both had surgery, so who can tell?

And Liz was having shit done before puberty.

R108, what did Liz have done before puberty?

Equal

Neither...that distinction belongs to Sandra Bernhard

Both

Gjjyuj

Taylor

Boyh

Liz

Now.

Taylor

Bofe

A tough one? Really? Liz.

They look the same to me

Equal

Liz

Tied

Gia.

Taylor

Ytef

Tied

Garbo over both

Carl

Hedy Lamarr

Gene Tierney

Stone

Miss Kay Lenz

Yuuu

Sophia

Mery

Gtre

Why hasn't anyone said Madonna?

There's no comparison. No one was more beautiful than Elizabeth Taylor in her prime.

They look similar

Twins

Rosemond

It's not hard at all. Elizbeth Taylor. Madonna is a very pretty woman, but EZ had a rare beauty.

As beautiful as Elizabeth Taylor, but in a completely different way, would Ingrid Bergman.

Liz in Place in the Sun.

R145, what do you mean by "would Ingrid Bergman"? Just wondering

R147

I'm in a difficult spot because I inadvertently blocked myself and can't read all my responses unless someone refers to them in a comment. I think I meant Bergman would be considered as beautiful as Taylor but in a very different way. Both women were luminously beautiful and although they could play lower-class, unrefined women, there was always something classy about them. Sophia Loren also has that quality. Madonna even at her most attractive, had a cheesy, trashy air. She cultivated it as a persona.

R148, I see what you mean

Princess Diana

OP, it's not a 'tough' decision. It's irrelevant.

R151, why irrelevant?

Princess Diana

Ingrid Bergman or Catherine Deneuve

Mae West

Marilyn Monroe

Not 1 vote for Madonna...why?

Madonna is more of a natural classic beauty

Chloe Jones

ET.

Both are dykes. Madonna has a man's physique. You don't need gaydar. All of the men connected to Madonna and Liz were gay.

They both look the exact same to me..I can't tell them apart.

Twins separated at birth

Madonna doesn't even fall in the same category of beauty as Liz Taylor. Liz was known for her beauty even as a child. She had black hair with violet eyes and pale skin. An exquisite looking woman. Madonna on the other hand was sexy but with that gap tooth and sleazy image? Hardly someone I would call beautiful. Compared to the way she looks now she might be but .....no.

Equal

I watched an interview Barbara Walters did with Elizabeth when she was in her 60's and she was talking about her many marriages, etc. and she looked beautiful and has a lovely warm funny personality. Great sense of humor. Madonna isn't in the same league.

Princess Diana

Neither of them were ever attractive in my eyes.

I never thought Diana was beautiful. Not the descriptive I'd use. She was very attractive. But honestly Diana was very, "masculine" in her features. She was athletic too. Perfect mother for boys if she wasn't so unstable.

Taylor was a Star. Madge impersonates stars.

R168, who are the most beautiful women ever to you?

They both are tied for being the most beautiful woman ever

Both

Tied

That's impossible to answer

Both 2 different 2 compare

Are they at all similar?

If so, then how?

Elizabeth Taylor.

.....

Elizabeth. Madonna had a better body but in Liz's Era women weren't expected to be muscle-bound.

^ era

I like the fact that Liz enjoyed food, booze, bawdy stories, and jewelry. She did a lot to raise awareness for AIDS.

Liz looks more like Jean Simmons and Madonna looks more like Marlene Dietrich.

Hmmm

Anna Nicole Smith

Hedy

Rosemond

Tied for eternity

Who?

Bump

Anna

Bump

Parilt

Elizabeth Taylor of course. Liz, was the epitome of a star, in her prime. Madonna was.also the epitome of a Pop Star. Madonna can't touch ET in looks though.

Both are beautiful but Madonna is more of a natural beauty.

Janet

Saks? The 99 cent store? Both have gorgeous cosmetics!

Bump

Greta Garbo

Bump

OP It's only a tough choice for the blind.

R201, I actually don't think Elizabeth became beautiful until she turned 15.

When did both look their absolute best?

Sharon

No one

Taylor

Who aged better?

When did they both look their best?

Madonna was known more for her natural classic beauty.

Should have made a poll

Greta Garbo

Cher

Lizbith

Tied

Both

Anna Nicole Smith

Country

Tied

Elizabeth Taylor

Lil kim