The Cookie Smeller's Yearbook

Oh I hope this thread has legs. This could be hilarious.

Brilliant OP. She's also smelling a dozen Krispy Kremes.

Am I still a member?

R3 Of course, Ladybird. You're our Patroness!

And our Vice Patroness is of course, Miss Cameron Fontana, who is smelling ALL the bakeries in Columbus!

Sometimes when the chlorine dissipated, Tom smelled cookies.

Stockings were hung by the chimney with care.

They were smelling ALL the cookies there!

Who are they, R7?

When I did a search for vintage gay men they popped up.

He clearly didn’t use his pencils to do homework.

The guy OP posted is gorgeous, in fact they all are......

.....with the extreme exception of the one in R3, which has the face of a water buffalo. A water buffalo that has smelt cookies

Here is some much needed eye bleach for anyone that looked at R3's pic too long

I read that phrase a lot here but i have no idea of what means

Lucas Grabeel and this other QUEEN.

The 'smelling cookies' is definitely the stupidest saying on DL

It's fabulous.

r13 Error 1011 Ray ID: 5d5bf7305cfaea20 • 2020-09-20 13:41:43 UTC

Access denied

What happened?

The owner of this website (peoplepill.com) does not allow hotlinking to that resource (/media/people/bio/L/lucas-grabeel/Grabeel-Bleu.jpg).

Cloudflare Ray ID: 5d5bf7305cfaea20 • Your IP: 2601:547:580:60a0:88b0:f333:f106:22b5 • Performance & security by Cloudflare

Chief Justice John Roberts

R12

[quote]A way to say that someone looks like they are a homoxexual without saying it out loud. Because gay guys often have a look on their face like they are smelling cookies. It is from a Dane Cook standup comedy joke. That guy over by the bar is so smelling cookies.

From here

What, R16? What?

Hi. Are those peanut butter chip cookies I detect?

Lovely.

It's the big smile, flared nostrils.

Smelling cookies. Like Miss Fontana at R5

An entire truckload of cookies crashed and caught on fire

Eek, R22. We don't want him!

OP's guy looks very sweet. I hope he had a good life.

Me too R24

and the cute boys at R7 too

Brooklyn just got a new shipment of freshly baked cookies

@r24, "OP's guy looks very sweet. I hope he had a good life. "

The "sweet" looking ones are always the biggest back-stabbing cunts

That pic of John Roberts is soooooo incriminating!

it certainly is

It's funny that Dane Cook claims to have originated this. Pot, meet kettle.

R7--Guy on the left resembles my Pop.

R20--I like the guy's earrings, they look like they may be copper enamel. Would look better with a caftan.

What, no cookie smeller's handbook?

Literally.

you can be an old queen and still note the aroma

[post redacted because linking to dailymail.co.uk clearly indicates that the poster is either a troll or an idiot (probably both, honestly.) Our advice is that you just ignore this poster but whatever you do, don't click on any link to this putrid rag.]

cookie COOKIE

I do declare, I smell snickerdoodles! Tee hee!

I feel bad posting this because this kid was just killed in a rodeo accident, (Now THERE’S something you don’t hear every day!) but as soon as I saw his pic, I had to find this thread.

R38 - don't feel too bad because when I saw his pic I thought the same thing!

gay? or gayer?

I smell something. . .

This must have been the faculty adviser

"...and irons his tie."

Not without a pressing cloth, I'm sure.

Who is the old guy with silver hair who looks like Boris Yeltsin?

The guy at r3, r44? Why that's Mrs. Michelle Bachmann.

"Ladybird", to her admirers.

Retired Admiral Bob Harward...

I always wanted to be a Rear Admiral. Or reared by an Admiral. Or something.

[quote]I smell something. . .

In your case, it was probably your unwashed ass, Aaron.

What is the story of the pic of Justice Roberts? 100% 1980's gathering of the gays.

[quote]SMELL IT!

I'd like to take a peek at it first r35, but okay.

Yes, who are the other men with Justice Roberts and where are they and are they playing with each other's dingalings?

The guy at R47 can smell MY cookies!

R10's photo appears to be of a young man smelling a small chocolate cake rather than cookies. As there is one balanced carefully on his head, this is not surprising.

R47, that is not what I'd call the smell of cookies. Napalm in the morning, more like.

R55 How about this picture? And remember: Harward is a retired VICE Admiral...

"Of rears and vices I have had quite enough. Now pray do not think I make a pun"

Jane Austin, "Mansfield Park"

R57 I love it!! Thank you!

R21, I agree with your comments, but I'd also mention that I think it's the eyebrows AND the game show host / televangelist smile.

On the photos that ping to me, it seems there's something up about the eyebrows. Maybe they are too primped and manicured, maybe the surprised elated look, but there's something about the eyebrows and the forced surprised smile.

US Surgeon General on a closed beach with his "Friend" during a pandemic. In Hawaii! Why the fuck isn't this guy on the pandemic task force? Oh, black, cookie-smeller.

My favorite old yearbook pic - a HS teacher from Gary, Indiana.

R61 that's much more "just now stepped squarely on a tack" than "smelling cookies".

He looks like a maniac at r47, but at r56, he looks like he’s just whipped up a batch of shortbread.

Life IS a mystery. Everyone has to stand alone at some point or other...

R44 yeah thats Bachmann. Boris Yeltsin was much better looking than that. And not really a cookie smeller

Cookies?? Do I smell cookies??

What? No Miz Lindz?

Pussy hound

Pic from an '80's yearbook - am I right or am I right?

Hot - but something gives him away...

Is THIS how you smell the cookies? It's how I would.

Out and proud!

Cookies and nipples that could cut glass.

That is an extremely hairy ass at r70. And sweaty too.