Libby's Holman was a washed up mediocre club singer and a wannabe talent best known for murdering her wealthy husband, Zachary Smith Reynolds heir to the R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Company. She met Monty around 1942 when she decided to revive her ailing career in theatre. According to the Patricia Bosworth biography at that time Monty was a fresh-faced 22 year old who only drank milk, she was almost 40 and desperately wanted him, mainly because he was an incredible beauty and an exceptional talent— something she could never be. Photos of Libby, some with Monty from the late 40s to early 50s (the duration of their relationship) show her to be extremely unattractive, prune-skinned and almost looks like she has down syndrome. I find it hard to believe he would have a intimate sexual relationship with this unappealing woman but turned down Elizabeth Taylor who was considered one of the most stunningly beautiful women of that era? It doesn't make sense. Both the Bosworth and Robert LaGuardia biographies teeter between bisexual and homosexual, but if he was bisexual why would he not sleep with her? Every guy in Hollywood and beyond wanted a piece of Liz so why not? He professed to love her and found her arousing (which for some reason was a surprise to him) so what happened? And why go to the extent of cruelly taunting her in such a way by leading her on only to flaunt his male lovers in her face and make a mockery of her love for him?
Is it possible he stayed with Libby because 1) she supplied him with endless drugs 2) His domineering, obsessive, control-freak mother 'Sunny' despised her, hence Monty used her for petty annoyance to get back at mum? Although it's not entirely clear when Monty started taking hard drugs or where he got them from I have no doubt it was Libby who introduced him to cocaine, opioids and tranquillisers. She was a bitterly jealous woman, especially of young attractive women who would buzz around Monty non-stop so of course she would need some way to rule over him.
Also in the biographies according to Brooks (Monty's hot mess of a brother) claims Monty couldn't be gay because he got two girls pregnant, but the bio's don't seem to go into any depth about these alleged pregnancies, it almost seems like it's glossed over entirely, which is strange given that they mentioned numerous times how Monty sincerely wanted children and a traditional family. The only other account is by "Rick" one of Monty's lovers who said one day Monty came to borrow a large sum of money from him said to him one of his girlfriend's was pregnant, but Rick never felt the need to ask questions just handed over the money.
Both biographies were great reads I thoroughly enjoyed them and definitely recommend if you're into old Hollywood and gossip. But I really want to know more information about Monty's male lovers something the bio's didn't really dive into, for obvious reasons. Roddy McDowall, why was Monty so cruel to him, what could he have done to deserve such scorn? And did he really attempt suicide after their breakup? Jerome Robbins, did Monty really break-off with him because his movie career was taking off or because of his involvement with the House Committee of Unamerican Activities? Jack Larson, Kevin McCarthy, did Monty have a thing for the McCarthy's, specifically Kevin? there's a home movie clip of him giving Kevin an aggressive Eskimo kiss.... and the others. If anyone has any information, tidbits, theories and speculations please share.