The Sue Mengers Story...
Dominick knew Mengers's boyfriend, Jean-Claude Tramont, from his days producing The Robert Montgomery Show at NBC. Back then, the man's name was Jack Schwartz and he lived with his mother in the Bronx . Dunne didn't bring it up when the three of them met in Paris but Tramont acknowledged Dunne. This irked Mengers.
"It was not that she did not know that his name had been Jack Schwartz. She did. What she hated about the encounter was that I knew," Dunne later remarked.
One good thing about Dunne's next film was that its screenwriters left him out of the picture. The bad thing was that Jean-Claude Tramont wrote the screenplay, and he could not write. Compounding the script problems was Mengers, whose recommendation to Paramount Pictures led to Dominick being named the producer on Ash Wednesday. It was a favor for his casting so many of her clients in Play It As It Lays. It was also a favor that would end his career in Hollywood.
Besides being a paying job, Ash Wednesday possessed one big plus -- at least for someone as chronically star-struck as Dominick.
"An Elizabeth Taylor movie!' he gushed. "That's a big deal." He decided to forget (as did Robert Evans, head of Paramount) that the actress had not made a hit movie in more than four years, and as her box-office clout shrank, her outrageous and costly behavior on and off set exploded.
Luchino Visconti was lobbying hard to get his boyfriend a part in Ash Wednesday. He entertained Dunne one night, showing him his new film "Ludwig," starring his boyfriend, Helmut Berger, whom the European press called "The Most Beautiful Man in the World." After the screening Visconti and Dominick chatted, and among other topics the legendary director launched into a complaint about today's young actors "who have everything handed to them."
Berger interrupted the older man. "You think it's easy fucking you every night? he asked.
Dominick could not resist casting such an actor. And this time Dominick got lucky, becoming one of Berger's many off-the-set conquests during production.
Jean-Claude Tramont tried to rewrite the script to Dunne's satisfaction but was not up to the job. He also turned himself into something of a joke on the set when he gave everybody gifts of T.S. Eliot's poem "Ash Wednesday" and signed them "With best wishes, Jean-Claude."
Pretentiousness laced with lack of talent is never endearing, and to the amusement of his actors Dominick revealed that Tramont also qualified as a complete phony. "I'd known him when he called himself Jack Schwartz and was an usher at NBC when I was doing live TV," Dominick told them. Taylor also hated the script and thought less of the man who wrote it when her butler overheard Tramont launch into a scathing critique of the star's questionable taste in clothes. She told Dominick, "Get that asshole off the set!" He had two choices: alienate Sue Mengers, who helped get him the job; or alienate his star, who threatened to become even more intractable.
After a disastrous autumn screening of the movie in Los Angeles, Dominick repeated one more time his story about Jean-Claude Tramont being Jack Schwartz from the Bronx. But in this latest retelling, he added a quip about the zaftig agent Sue Mengers, whom Tramont had now married.
"One day, if the true story of this film is ever told, it should be called "When a Fat Girl Falls in Love," said Dominick. He even said he was writing a book about the making of the movie and calling it "When a Fat Girl Falls in Love." He was not writing such a book, but he thought it sounded funny. At the time.
When Robert Evans read the story in the Reporter, which was retold as fact, he called Dominick and told him. "You'll never work in this town again!""