The Ugly But Actual Pretty One

Lori Saunders to Gunilla Hutton

True dat.

Stafford Repp to Neal Hamilton

JC Chasez to Justin Timberlake

The DUFF.

Joyce was much prettier than Suzanne. Joyce ruined her looks with the ill advised nose job(s). Suzanne Somers had a very average looking face.

In the long debate of Ginger vs Mary Ann, Mary Ann always wins by a wide margin. But yeah, Ginger was portrayed as the sex symbol at the time it was originally airing.

On Smallville, the cute & natural Allison Mack versus the pretty (but botoxed to the frozen-faced hilt) Erica Durance.

Harry to Wills.

After Season 1, Rhoda Morgenstern to Mary Richards.

Fuck you, OP.

Rhea Perlman to Kirstie Alley, 1990

Kirstie Alley to Rhea Perlman, 2015

Nancy McKeon to Lisa Whelchel

What does this actually mean?

Betty Buckley to Dianne Kay

R13 to Dl

Marlon to LaToya

Stevie Nicks is ALWAYS the much prettier and much more beautiful one over Christine McVie.

Lindsey over Stevie

Chachi to Joanie.

Kate Jackson to Farrah Fawcett

Bridget Jones to Natasha

Jaclyn Smith to Farrah

Courtney Cox to Jennifer Aniston

Desi to Lucy

Shannen Doherty to Facinelli's ex-wife...

Scott Michael Foster to Chace Crawford...

Mary Ann Mobley to Dixie Carter

The Wicked Witch of the West to Dorothy

Melanie C (Sporty) to the other Spice Girls

Lisa over Jen

Any queen over Caroline in the city - including the rollerskate bottom

Corky over Patty LU pone

Kelly Rowland to Beyonce

Dawn Wells and Tina Louise were both gorgeous on "Gilligan's Island".

Michelle to Melania

r32

Not even I believe that

Velma to Daphne

Betty to Veronica

So basically the Brunette to the Blonde

R35 Betty was the blonde over brunette Veronica.

Betty Rubble over Wilma Flintstone

and their human counterparts:

Trixie Norton over Alice Kramden

Julia over Suzanne Sugarbaker

Rose over Blanche

Blanche over Jane

Ethel over Lucy

Justin Hartley to Tom Welling

They were both pretty - but I preferred Parker Stevenson while Sean Cassidy was the one that got all the media as the next hot thing.

Joan Fontaine over Livy - not that this caused any problems!

Dawn Wells was never 'the ugly one." She was cute as hell. A lot of men preferred her Mary Ann to Tina Louise's Ginger.

R45, I didn't realize how pretty Mary Ann was until years later. Ginger overshadowed her. Kinda like a trans woman to a naturally born woman.

I am guessing this one has already been mentioned - while Bailey (Jan Smithers) was never considered ugly all the men drooled over Jennifer (Lonnie Anderson) on WKRP. I thought Lonnie was actually great as Jennifer and she was a great character, but always felt she looked more like a caricature or mannequin.

Nancy Kulp to Donna Douglas.

The Crypt Keeper to Kellyanne

R46 a tranny can never overshadow a woman.

George Harrison to Paul McCartney

Caitlyn over Kris

Lol @ R49

Charlie Watts over Mick Jagger

Peter Tork over Davy Jones

Scrappy over Scoobie.

R20 Jacklyn Smith over Farrah Fawcett

Joe Hackett over Brian Hackett.

They're equally attractive, but I believe Brian got more attention from women than Joe did.

Got=had

Dorothy Malone over Lauren Bacall in Howard Hawk's The Big Sleep (1946)

Suzanne Somers was beautiful during first season of Three's company before she changed her hair and tried to be goofy (with that snorting laughter).

Barney Fife to Andy Griffin

Reba to Barbra Jean

Ally Sheedy was just as pretty as Molly in The Breakfast Club.

Dorian over Viki

I think of it not as ugly/pretty, but as "girl next door" vs. "head cheerleader" archetypes.

Shirley over Laverne

Jo over Blair

Allie over Kate

Cathy Lane over Patty Lane.

The Professor over both Dawn Welles and Tina Louise!

Dorothy to Rose

Bea to Betty

Sterling K. Brown over Justin Hartley on "This Is Us."

Mike Brady over Marcia Brady

Lou over Sue Ann

The entire male cast of [italic]Silver Spoons[/italic] over Erin Gray

Aunt Esther over Fred Sanford. Fred made Esther look like a super model.

Miss Cillian Murphy to Every Actress

Ted Lawson over that beard of his who also played the teacher who tried to kill Billy Tate

John Davidson over Lesley Ann Warren

Christopher Atkins over Lesley Ann Warren

Christopher Knight over Florence Henderson

Christopher Plummer over Julie Andrews

James Garner over Julie Andrews

John Gavin over Julie Andrews

Cal Bartlett over either Julie Andrews or Helen Reddy

Tommy Kirk over Annette Funicello (or any of the women Walt Disney or Sam Arkoff tried to stick him with)

Gordon MacRae over Shirley Jones

Robert Preston over Shirley Jones

Dave Madden and David Cassidy over Shirley Jones

Robert Preston over Lucille Ball

Albert Finney, Tim Curry and Geoffrey Holder over Ann Reinking, Bernadette Peters, and Carol Burnett

Roy Scheider, Cliff Gorman, Ben Vereen, John Lithgow and all the gay male dancers in [italic]All That Jazz[/italic] over Ann Reinking

Jonathan Silverman over Nell Carter

Sarah Huckabee and Sarah Silverman. = tie

I thought all the Angels were pretty than Farrah.

Agree with R9 Rhoda over Mary and after re-watching some episodes last week Phyllis over both of them big-time.

Carla over Sam and Diane.

Jackie over Sarah

-Deborah Van Valkenburgh

Baby Jane over Blanche

Betty White over Rue McClanahan